New questions: which role do the very deep ocean waters play in climate change?

Hendrik Averkamp: „A Winter Scene with Two Gentlemen Playing Colf“ circa 1615-1620, Los Angeles, J. Paul Getty Museum. Source: <a href=""target="_blank">Wikimedia Commons</a>

Whereas most of the Pacific is responding to modern warming, the ocean under 2000 m depth may be cooling due to waters from the Little Ice Age

The ocean has a long memory. When the water in today’s deep Pacific Ocean last saw sunlight, Charlemagne was the Holy Roman Emperor, the Song Dynasty ruled China and Oxford University had just held its very first class. During that time, between the 9th and 12th centuries, the earth’s climate was generally warmer before the cold of the Little Ice Age settled in around the 16th century. Now ocean surface temperatures are back on the rise but the question is, do the deepest parts of the ocean follow that?

Researchers from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI) and Harvard University have found that the deep Pacific Ocean lags a few centuries behind in terms of temperature and is still adjusting to the entry into the Little Ice Age.

Whereas most of the ocean is responding to modern warming, the deep Pacific may be cooling.

In other words: Cold waters that sank in polar regions hundreds of years ago are still impacting deep Pacific Ocean temperature trends – but that does not mean that the climate at the surface is not heating up, the question is how the two phenomena are linked together.

The so-called Little Ice Age was a period of extremely cold winters documented by Dutch painters depicting scenes of people ice-skating on the country’s waterways. It is usually dated from around 1400 until 1850.

„These Pacific waters are so old and haven’t been near the surface in so long, they still ,remember’ what was going on hundreds of years ago when Europe experienced some of its coldest winters in history,” said Jake Gebbie, a physical oceanographer at WHOI and lead author of the study published in the journal Science.

„Climate varies across all timescales,“ adds Peter Huybers, Professor of Earth and Planetary Sciences at Harvard University and co-author of the paper. „Some regional warming and cooling patterns, like the Little Ice Age and the Medieval Warm Period, are well known. Our goal was to develop a model of how the interior properties of the ocean respond to changes in surface climate.“

What that model showed was surprising.

„Those parts of the ocean most isolated from modern warming may still be cooling,” said Gebbie.

The model is, of course, a simplification of the actual ocean. To test the prediction, Gebbie and Huybers compared the cooling trend found in the model to ocean temperature measurements taken by scientists aboard the HMS Challenger in the 1870s and modern observations from the World Ocean Circulation Experiment of the 1990s.

Hendrik Averkamp: „A scene on the ice circa 1625“, Washington, D.C., National Gallery of Art. Source: <a href=""target="_blank">Wikimedia Commons</a>

The HMS Challenger, a three-masted wooden sailing ship originally designed as a British warship, was used for the first modern scientific expedition to explore the world’s ocean and seafloor. During the expedition from 1872 to 1876, thermometers were lowered into the ocean depths and more than 5,000 temperature measurements were logged.

„We screened this historical data for outliers and considered a variety of corrections associated with pressure effects on the thermometer and stretching of the hemp rope used for lowering thermometers,“ said Huybers.

The researchers then compared the HMS Challenger data to the modern observations and found warming in most parts of the global ocean, as would be expected due to the warming planet over the 20th Century, but cooling in the deep Pacific at a depth of around two kilometers.

„The close correspondence between the predictions and observed trends gave us confidence that this is a real phenomenon,“ said Gebbie.

These findings imply that variations in surface climate that predate the onset of modern warming still influence how much the climate is heating up today. Previous estimates of how much heat the Earth had absorbed during the last century assumed an ocean that started out in equilibrium at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution. But Gebbie and Huybers estimate that the deep Pacific cooling trend leads to a downward revision of heat absorbed over the 20th century by about 30 percent.

„Part of the heat needed to bring the ocean into equilibrium with an atmosphere having more greenhouse gases was apparently already present in the deep Pacific,“ said Huybers. „These findings increase the impetus for understanding the causes of the Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice Age as a way for

Source: Woods Hole Oceonographic Institution

(11.04.2019, USA: 04.11.2019)